If you visited crownandcaliber.com recently, you probably noticed something strange. There are no watch listings. No buy or sell options. No marketplace at all — just editorial content about watches.
For anyone who used Crown & Caliber to buy or sell a pre-owned timepiece, that shift raises a fair question: did the company go out of business?
The short answer is no — but the full story is more complicated than that. Here is a clear account of what Crown & Caliber was, what Hodinkee’s acquisition meant, why that deal eventually unraveled, and what the brand actually is today.
What Crown & Caliber Was and How It Built Its Reputation
Crown & Caliber was founded in 2013 in Atlanta, Georgia. It operated as an e-commerce platform focused on pre-owned luxury watches — a space that was still maturing in the U.S. at the time.
Its core offering was straightforward: a professional, trustworthy way to buy and sell secondhand watches. The platform provided authenticity guarantees and built a strong content presence alongside its marketplace operations.
Over time, Crown & Caliber grew into one of the more respected names in the U.S. secondhand watch market. It was not the biggest player globally, but it had earned a reputation for reliability — which made it an attractive acquisition target.
Hodinkee Acquired Crown & Caliber in 2021 for an Ambitious Reason
In February 2021, Hodinkee — one of the most widely read watch media and retail companies in the world — acquired Crown & Caliber. The deal was announced with genuine enthusiasm on both sides.
Crown & Caliber founder Hamilton Powell published an open letter describing the acquisition as a chance to build what he called the number one solution for buying and selling pre-owned luxury watches. The logic made sense on paper.
Hodinkee had a large, engaged audience of watch enthusiasts. Crown & Caliber had the operational infrastructure and pre-owned expertise. Together, the idea was to combine media reach with a functioning secondhand marketplace.
The integration plans were specific. Hodinkee announced it would bring Crown & Caliber’s pre-owned inventory into the Hodinkee Shop, and customers would be able to use Crown & Caliber trade-in credits directly on Hodinkee. All Crown & Caliber employees remained in Atlanta, and both brands initially continued operating under their own identities.
On paper, it looked like a smart vertical integration. In practice, it did not hold together for long.
Why Hodinkee Eventually Decided to Exit the Pre-Owned Watch Business
The post-pandemic period was difficult for the luxury pre-owned segment. Demand that had surged during the pandemic — particularly for watches like Rolex and Patek Philippe — began to soften as broader economic conditions shifted. Prices on the secondary market corrected, and platforms built around that speculative momentum felt the pressure.
Reporting from Bloomberg, republished by BusinessMirror, described Hodinkee’s move into online used watch sales as “ill-advised.” That is a notable characterization for a deal that had been framed only a few years earlier as an obvious strategic fit.
Hodinkee eventually made a broader decision: it would stop selling both new and secondhand watches entirely, and refocus its business model away from direct retail. That shift set the stage for the Crown & Caliber divestment.
Around the same time, Watches of Switzerland acquired Hodinkee. But Crown & Caliber was explicitly excluded from that transaction. National Jeweler confirmed that the brand had already been sold separately before the Watches of Switzerland deal was finalized.
European Watch Company Bought the Brand — But Not the Inventory
In October 2024, Hodinkee sold Crown & Caliber’s digital assets to European Watch Company, a Boston-based pre-owned watch dealer. This is the transaction that effectively determined what Crown & Caliber is today.
A few details from that sale are worth understanding clearly.
No watches were included in the deal. European Watch Company did not acquire any inventory. The sale covered the website, the brand name, and the digital platform — nothing else.
The price reflected how far the asset had fallen. The sale was reported in the “low six figures.” That is a stark contrast to the roughly $46 million Hodinkee reportedly paid for the company in 2021. Within three years, the valuation had collapsed by an order of magnitude.
The business model changed fundamentally. European Watch Company indicated it would integrate Crown & Caliber’s e-commerce platform into its own operations. The Crown & Caliber website itself would no longer sell products. Instead, the brand would continue through blogs, YouTube, and social media — a content presence, not a marketplace.
According to publicly available information, Crown & Caliber formally relaunched as an online lifestyle magazine in February 2026, with European Watch Company as publisher. The brand is active, but it is no longer a place where you can list a watch for sale or browse pre-owned inventory.
So Is Crown & Caliber Going Out of Business?
Not exactly — but the business that most customers knew is gone.
The original Crown & Caliber marketplace, where you could sell a Rolex or browse pre-owned Omegas, no longer operates under that name or on that website. If you return to crownandcaliber.com expecting to buy or sell, you will find editorial content instead.
The distinction worth drawing is between business continuity and brand continuity. The transactional business — the buying, selling, inventory management, and marketplace operations — has effectively ceased on that platform. But the brand name, website, and content channels are still active under European Watch Company’s ownership.
A useful comparison: imagine a well-known bookstore brand that gets acquired, then later sold again, and the new owner turns it into a book review publication. The store stopped selling books, but the name and voice carried on in a different form. That is roughly what has happened here.
What This Means for Customers Who Used Crown & Caliber
If you previously bought or sold watches through Crown & Caliber, there are a few practical things to understand.
The marketplace is no longer operational on crownandcaliber.com. Anyone looking for a similar service will need to turn to European Watch Company directly, or explore other pre-owned watch platforms.
Any questions about past transactions, warranties, or trade-in credits are more complicated. Depending on when your transaction occurred, the relevant policies may sit with Hodinkee or European Watch Company. If you have open questions, contacting those companies directly is the most reliable path. The specifics of what each company has agreed to honor are not fully detailed in public reporting.
Crown & Caliber’s content is still there. The editorial library, YouTube videos, and social channels continue to operate. If you followed Crown & Caliber for watch reviews and market commentary, that part of the brand is still accessible.
What the Broader Business Story Tells Us
The trajectory of Crown & Caliber offers a clear example of how quickly niche e-commerce valuations can shift. Hodinkee paid what was reported as approximately $46 million for a pre-owned watch platform at a moment of high market optimism. A few years later, during a cooler market environment, the digital assets sold for a fraction of that — reportedly in the low six figures.
That kind of value erosion is not unique to the watch industry. It reflects a pattern seen across niche retail and media hybrids: high valuations during growth periods, followed by a difficult reckoning when market conditions change or the strategic logic does not translate into execution.
For readers interested in how media companies navigate retail expansion — and the risks involved — the Crown & Caliber story is worth studying. Publications like CloudBizMag track these kinds of business model shifts across industries, and this case fits a recurring pattern.
The other side of the story is that a trusted brand name retains value even when its underlying business model fails. European Watch Company did not pay much for Crown & Caliber’s digital assets, but it paid something — because the name, audience, and content library still carried weight in the watch world.
The Bottom Line
Crown & Caliber did not go bankrupt. It was not liquidated. But the business that watch enthusiasts used to buy and sell pre-owned timepieces has been effectively wound down as a direct retail operation.
Hodinkee acquired Crown & Caliber in 2021 with a clear strategic vision. That vision did not survive the post-pandemic market shift. Hodinkee eventually exited both the new and pre-owned watch retail business, and Crown & Caliber’s digital assets were sold to European Watch Company for a fraction of the original purchase price.
Today, Crown & Caliber exists as a watch-focused media brand. If you visit the site expecting a marketplace, you will not find one. But the brand is not gone — it has simply become something different than what it was.
Read Also:
